My girlfriend of 3 years broke up with me because of cigars

[dave]

Originally Posted by T.G

No you were not.

If that was how it was going to go down, then it's better it ended now than a few years down the road.

Exactly what I was going to wrote. T.G. is also wise.

I'm curious, though about a couple things..
1. It sounds as though you were making an effort to hide it from her. Still, good riddance, but maybe more than just a controlling witch and cigars going on here.
2. If you HAD told her you smoke cigars, what do you think she'd have said? If your next x gives you an ultimatum about cigars....or any other legal (or ethical?) pastime....run.